What Quiet Quitting Tells Us About Consumers: It’s Not Just a Workplace Trend

Over the past few years, quiet quitting has captured headlines and sparked debate about employee engagement. But what if this behavioral shift isn’t just happening inside the workplace?

What if it’s happening across the board with consumers, too?

At Sage Outcomes, we believe this isn’t just an HR issue, it’s a signal of a broader shift in expectations and behaviors. And it has major implications for how brands build trust, foster loyalty, and innovate for the future.

‍

Reframing Quiet Quitting: Beyond the Workplace

Gallup defines quiet quitting as doing only what’s required; no more, no less. It’s often a response to burnout, unclear expectations, or a breakdown in trust between employees and employers.

But let’s zoom out.

What if that same emotional pullback is happening in the marketplace?

Consumers, like employees, are reevaluating their relationships with the brands they buy from. They’re opting out of loyalty programs, skipping the surveys, not recommending products, and choosing competitors without warning. The connection is transactional, not emotional - and that’s a risk.

‍

Psychological Contracts: It’s About More Than Transactions

In HR theory, a psychological contract is the unspoken agreement between an employee and employer. It outlines what each side expects, beyond the written job description. When that contract is breached, disengagement follows.

Can this same concept apply to consumers that interact with your brand? 

Brands make promises about experience, values, personalization, ease - and when those promises go unmet, consumers quietly walk away. No complaints. No feedback. Just churn.

It’s not that they don’t care. It’s that they no longer expect better.

‍

The Cost of Consumer Disengagement

McKinsey estimates that employee disengagement can cost organizations as much as 4% of wage bills, a number that doesn’t include reputational damage or missed growth opportunities.

Now apply that thinking to your consumer base.

• What is the cost of a disengaged customer who no longer advocates for your brand?
• How much value is lost when consumers stop giving feedback that helps you improve?
• What does it mean when buyers expect to be disappointed? Can you think of a brand you no longer trust? What would they have to do to win you back (if it were even possible)?

As with employees, the silent withdrawal of engagement signals something deeper: a lack of trust and unmet expectations.

As a result, you’ve likely seen these “quiet quitting behaviors” in your customers before. They’re the signals many brands miss or misinterpret:

• No brand loyalty actions: They buy, but don’t refer. They unsubscribe from your newsletter. They use ad blockers.
• Minimal engagement: They skip your upsell prompts. They don’t complete satisfaction surveys. They don't participate in your community.
• Cognitive disengagement: They stop expecting delight. They don’t read the fine print. They assume disappointment.
• Silent churn risk: They quietly leave … and they don’t tell you why.

And just like in the workplace, the root causes often come down to misaligned expectations, lack of perceived value, and burnout from being marketed to constantly without real relevance or reward.

Let’s Redefine: How Brands Can Respond

If consumers are quiet quitting, how do you earn back their trust?

1. Audit your promises: Are you over-promising and under-delivering? Consumers remember unmet expectations.
2. Prioritize recognition: Are you rewarding loyalty, not just acquisition? Do long-time customers feel appreciated?
3. Watch for apathy, not just complaints: Quiet disengagement is harder to track, but perhaps more telling. Gathering NPS data is a great way to see who’s championing your business (promoters), who’s losing your business (detractors), and who’s apathetic (passives.
4. Use consumer insights as an early warning system: Ongoing market research can uncover shifts in expectations before they show up in your KPIs.
5. Humanize your brand: Just like employees want to be seen, consumers want to feel understood. Authenticity and empathy still matter.
   
   

Let’s Not Miss the Signal

Quiet quitting isn't just a workplace trend. It’s a window into how people (whether employees or consumers) respond to unmet expectations, misaligned values, and emotional fatigue.

If your consumers are pulling back, it’s not just about your product. It’s about the trust they’ve lost or the expectations that feel broken.

At Sage Outcomes, we help brands uncover these deeper insights before the churn, before the silence, and before the opportunity is lost.

📥 Want to stay ahead of evolving consumer expectations?
Let’s talk about how our insight-driven approach can help you re-engage and retain your most valuable audiences.

‍